Best Pizza Slice 2024 | Food + Drink

Best of Halifax

Best Pizza Slice

Yeah Yeahs Pizza, Best of Halifax 2024 gold winner of Best Pizza Slice

GOLD WINNER

???? Yeah Yeahs Pizza
website

SILVER WINNER

???? Salvatore’s Pizzaiolo Trattoria
website

BRONZE WINNER

???? On The Wedge Gourmet Pizza
website

HONOURABLE MENTIONS

Jubilee Junction
Morris East Restaurant + Wine Bar
Sapori Italian Street Food
Triple A Convenience & Pizzeria

Yeah Yeahs Pizza, located on Ochterloney Street in Dartmouth and on Oxford Street in Halifax, is committed to “high quality ingredients done simple and well,” according to co-owner Josh Nordin. Its two best-selling slices are the margherita and its classic pepperoni—which contains pepperoni that Yeah Yeahs acquires from an undisclosed source. That’s right: Proprietary pepperoni. 

“We source these rad, tiny little pepperonis that get really crispy in the oven,” explains Nordin. “It's definitely my favourite. And we do a different version of it, called the spicy pep—it’s got banana peppers, white onions and a little bit of honey. That's absolutely my favourite slice.”

The key to a Yeah Yeahs slice? Sticking with the principles that got them started in the first place, Nordin adds: “Even though every ingredient we use continues to go up in price, we’re just not willing to use an inferior product.”